The One Makeup Product That Keeps Shine Away If you thought it was easy to get shiny on a normal day, imagine being up on stage under hot lights while singing your heart out — and yet, the contestants' makeup never actually looks it. The secret: NYX Professional Makeup Shine Killer Charcoal Infused Mattifying Primer ($14). "That's been a lifesaver lately," said Green. "It cuts down the amount of touch-ups you have to do." Image Source: ulta.com NYX Professional Makeup Shine Killer Charcoal Infused Mattifying Primer $14 from ulta.com Buy Now