Stock up on staple eye makeup with this IT Cosmetics Superhero Superstar Lash, Liner & Brow Set ($21, originally $35). It comes with a volumizing and lengthening mascara that will give your lashes a fluttery look from root to tip, a gel-based eyeliner that is waterproof, pigmented, and long-wearing, plus an eyebrow pencil in a universally flattering shade that gives your brows a natural, fuller look.