When Ashley returned to paradise during season three of the spinoff Bachelor in Paradise, she was ready to rekindle her on-and-off again relationship with Jared and made a pledge to only cry three times. She used her first cry when she quickly found out about Jared's new relationship with Caila Quinn. She reprimanded Caila, calling her a "backstabbing friend" for betraying her trust, and engaged in a heart to heart with a parrot.