With all the controversy surrounding Colton from the start (uh, he dated Becca's friend and former Bachelor contestant, Tia Booth), it didn't seem like he would make it that far. But the couple was able to move past it, and their relationship has been growing ever since. Colton is a bit of a bad boy, so that could work against him when it comes time to choose a new Bachelor. We'll have to see if he becomes a true fan favourite towards the end of the season.