At the beginning of the season, Brooke seemed the most likely candidate to be the final girl. But should she survive, wouldn't it be a little too obvious? Plus, as the plot thickened, she grew tougher and became less of a goody two-shoes. She slept with Ray's ghost, murdered Montana, served years in prison, and nearly almost died by lethal injection. Not to mention, she recently hacked up Dylan McDermott.
Another reason we have our doubts? Emma Roberts pretty much always dies, whether she's sawed in half in Freak Show or gets strangled to death in Coven.