When We Were Magic is a YA novel by Magic for Liars author Sarah Gailey. Alexis has always found a sense of belonging among her friends. They all share the gift of magic, and it is the thing that binds them. Nothing can break that bond . . . until prom night rolls around. When their magic gets out of hand and a boy ends up dead, Alexis and her friends have to try and put right the terrible wrong but end up making things worse. Now each of them must learn to live with the consequences of their actions.
Out now.