Socially awkward Catholic schoolgirl Mary Katherine Gallagher (Molly Shannon) dreams about dating popular student Sky Corrigan and becoming a star. In order to achieve her dreams, she enters a talent contest where her biggest rival is Sky's girlfriend Evian Graham (Elaine Hendrix). Against the wishes of her grandmother, Mary Katherine prepares to win both the contest and Sky's heart.
Memorable quotes:
- "I made up a new dance move. It's called the 'move on with your life.'"
- "Nice moves!"
- "I call this one, the pepper mill."
Superstar is currently available on Hulu with a Starz account.