Starring Jason Bateman and Rebecca Hall, this creepy chiller tells the story of married couple Simon and Robyn who randomly run into Simon's former high school classmate, Gordo, while out shopping one day. After the encounter, Gordo begins making unexpected visits and delivering mysterious gifts, and when a horrible secret comes to light, Robyn questions just how well she knows her husband. Critics are pretty divided about The Gift's shocking conclusion, but there's no denying that it's got quite the twist.
Watch The Gift on Netflix.