It only lasted one season, but 1995's American Gothic is a cult classic thanks its mix of supernatural storytelling and stellar performances (long before she was an American Horror Story regular, Sarah Paulson played the doomed Merlyn). Set in the small town of Trinity, South Carolina, the series centres on a corrupt sheriff with supernatural powers who is trying to gain control over his biological son, who may be the only person capable of bringing him down.
Watch American Gothic on Hulu.