Suddenly sentimental about his family's pre-Schitt's Creek Christmases, Johnny spends all of Christmas Eve attempting to organise a last-minute Christmas gathering at the motel. After accepting that he won't be able to pull it off, Johnny heads to the diner by himself. When he returns home, escorted by Moira, he finds that his family and the town have come together to celebrate. Marked by the rendition of "Silent Night," the Rose family are finally able to experience the spirit of Christmas at Schitt's Creek.