Will Toni and Shelby Pursue Their Relationship From the Island? While Toni and Shelby fight nearly the entire season, I was thrilled to see them finally kiss (then more) later in the show. Shelby becomes more assured of who she is and her interest in women, something Toni's been confident about for a while. When the two reunite, will they date and continue their relationship from the island, or will they go their separate ways? I hope to see more good things happen between them. Image Source: Everett Collection