A year after the accident, Johnny is now engaged to Eric (their former high school coach). While Alison (pretending to be Lennon) is the first one who receives the stalker's taunting message sprawled across her bedroom mirror in blood, Eric is, unfortunately, first to fall prey to their sinister machination in episode two. When Johnny drives to the gym to help Eric prepare for sports camp, he finds his fiancé motionless, trapped under a heavy barbell. Without realising the full scope of the trap, Johnny tries to remove the weights, only to release an adjoining dumbbell that pelts into Eric's face, killing him.