As part of Hulu's Into the Dark series, Pilgrim is a creepy look at historical reenactors gone awry. Spoiled housewife Anna (Courtney Henggeler) decides that this Thanksgiving, she's going to hire a bunch of people to cosplay as Pilgrims in order to re-create the first Thanksgiving — but in her home for her family. However, the "Pilgrims" show up way too early and tell Anna that they're going to immerse her family in Pilgrim ways. Things quickly devolve as the Pilgrims act stranger and the concept of what Thanksgiving actually is starts to blur. It goes beyond just psychological thriller, though, when things start to get seriously bloody.