If I didn't know better, I would have easily believed this Talenti Less Sugar Mint Cookie Crunch ($6) to be the real deal. It is creamy, minty, and has just the right amount of cookie crunch. A serving contains 13 grams of sugar (compared to 35 grams in the brand's Mediterranean Mint), so it's not the lowest carb count on the list, but the taste and quality made it worth it.