Probably the most reminiscent of good old-fashioned ice cream is Ben & Jerry's Chocolate Milk and Cookies Moo-Phoria ($59 for eight pints). This blend of chocolate and vanilla ice cream is packed with the big cookie chunks you'd expect from Ben & Jerry's, but with fewer calories and less sugar than the brand's regular pints. It does come at a price, though, which is why it didn't take the top spot — a serving contains 15 grams of sugar, more than many low-carb ice creams.