Chocolate vs. Vanilla: William Greenberg Desserts Famous Giant Black & White Cookies If you can't decide between chocolate and vanilla, the William Greenberg Desserts Famous Giant Black & White Cookies ($59 for 12) are made for you. They're soft cookies topped with half dark chocolate and half vanilla icing. Image Source: goldbelly.com William Greenberg Desserts Famous Giant Black & White Cookies $59 from goldbelly.com Buy Now