Wizard Hat Cake Topper What would a Harry Potter-themed party be without a stop by the old Sorting Hat? With this Wizard Hat Cake Topper ($13), you and your friends can officially be sorted into your own houses and eat your cake, too! You can get one large hat for a cake, or you can get packs of small hats for cupcakes so each of your fellow witches and wizards can have their very own Sorting Hat. Image Source: etsy.com Wizard Hat Cake Topper $13 from etsy.com Buy Now