A Reversible Option: Mystery Flip-A-Mallow Squishmallow Get this Mystery Flip-A-Mallow Squishmallow ($33) for a mystery reversible 12-inch Squishmallow. It'll be such a surprise and a fun find, especially if they don't have a reversible one! Image Source: claires.com Mystery Flip-A-Mallow Squishmallow $33 from claires.com Buy Now