"Leave it to makeup guru Pat McGrath to make lip gloss fun again. Her eponymous brand recently released its new Lust: Lip Gloss ($28) and its been a staple in my makeup bag ever since. It has a creamy texture that isn't sticky and comes in 14 versatile shades with a variety of finishes. I personally love smearing on Aphrodisiac (a rosy pink) then layering on Pale Fire Nectar (a shimmery coral) to create a three-dimensional effect." —AS