Wet n Wild Colour Icon Pencil This was the first eyeliner we ever tried, and we still keep it in our stash today. It comes in a wide variety of shades, the price is completely unbeatable, and (with the help of a carefully placed flame) it can even be transformed into a gel formula. Wet n Wild Colour Icon Liner Brow & Eye Pencil in Black ($1) Wet n Wild Colour Icon Liner Brow & Eye Pencil in Black $1 from target.com Buy Now