"Nyx Professional Makeup Jumbo Eye Pencil ($8) has been a part of my beauty collection since I first got my hands on it a few years ago because of its highly pigmented and creamy consistency that allows tons of playtime before it sets. Once it does, the pigment stays locked in (so long as the area doesn't get too oily). I'm bringing it back out this season because it's now a key part of the brand's new Wonderland After Dark bundles, which are curated to create some of the most memorable Halloween costume makeup of all time."