Smith & Cult Glitterbaby Metallic-Shift Eye Shadow When it comes to liquid eye shadow, creasing is our biggest dealbreaker. Luckily, the Smith & Cult Glitterbaby ($14) doesn't do that, ever — not even when you're sardined on the dance floor for approximately four hours. Image Source: ulta.com Smith & Cult Glitterbaby $14 from ulta.com Buy Now