For the Critics' Choice Awards, Pugh matched her makeup to her crystal-studded outfit, making for an incredibly pretty and sparkly result. Makeup artist Naoko Scintu used Surratt Beauty Lid Lacquer in Kira Kira as a creamy base, followed by a mix of three different shimmery eye shadows to create that bright, almost-holographic finish. To ensure Pugh's lids twinkled as much as possible, Scintu kept the rest of her makeup bronze-y with a neutral beige lip.