It's all here with this Sephora Collection Retractable Waterproof Eyeliner ($9-$13): There's a precise pencil tip (made even more perfect with a built-in sharpener) and a smudge brush so you don't need to touch your face to make a smoky eye. There are shimmer and matte choices available, depending on your own personal style — and more than 6,000 reviews from other shoppers to back it up, too.