Too Faced Melted Chocolate Liquid Matte Eye Shadow Each of the dessert-inspired shades of Too Faced Melted Chocolate Liquid Matte Eye Shadow ($21) features both primer and shadow in one tube, and a waterproof, long-lasting formula that sets matte and calorie-free. Image Source: sephora.com Too Faced Melted Chocolate Liquid Matte Eye Shadow $21 from sephora.com Buy Now