The Original MakeUp Eraser The Sponge The Original MakeUp Eraser The Sponge ($18) is already special because it's meant to be popped in that plastic ball and refreshed right in the washer and dryer . . . but its 4.7-star average rating doesn't hurt either. Image Source: sephora.com The Original MakeUp Eraser The Sponge $18 from sephora.com Buy Now