Actor and playwright Tracy Letts announced his engagement to Sarah in the late '90s, but the couple called it quits shortly after. In an interview, she explains, "I was young — 24. We loved each other, it just didn't work out." Tracy, who is nine years older than Sarah, is now married to The Leftovers' Carrie Coon, with whom he has three children.
Image Source: Getty/ Gary Gershoff