It's immediately clear that Catherine, a 26-year-old DJ from Florida, is not to be trusted when she gets out of the limo and proceeds to hand over her Pomeranian, Lucy, to Colton so that he can take care of the dog for the duration of Catherine's stay on the show. I'm going to go out on a limb and say this is all a funny gag staged by producers, but if it's not . . . well, at least we all have those shots of Chris Harrison taking Lucy out to pee in our minds forever.
But anyway, back to Catherine — though she's soft-spoken, she isn't afraid to steal Colton away from the other contestants. And then steal him again. And again. And again. "I'm sorry, I just really think we need to finish our conversation," she repeatedly tells the other women, who get more and more furious throughout the night.
Finally Onyeka, a 24-year-old risk consultant (an apt profession for this interaction, I must say), pulls Catherine aside to let her know everyone in the house straight up hates her is a little peeved at her disrespectful behaviour. (Note: this happens after Onyeka steals Colton from Catherine by barging into their conversation with a snorkeling mask and yelling, "Colton, I heard you were drowning in some bitches so I came to save you!") Despite her chat with Onyeka, Catherine continues stealing Colton at every turn, instantly labeling herself as this season's villain.