Popsugar Entertainment The Baby-Sitters Club The Babysitter's Club Cast Then and Now Ahead of the Netflix Revival, Check in With the Original Baby-Sitters Club 8 March 2019 by Amanda Prahl View On One Page Photo 5 of 11 ADVERTISEMENT () Start Slideshow Share This Link Copy ← Use Arrow Keys → 5 Rachael Leigh Cook (left) as Mary Anne Spier Previous Next Start Slideshow The Baby-Sitters ClubKid TV And MoviesNostalgiaMovies