Miss North Carolina 2018 (and runner-up to Miss USA that year) had an apparent connection with Colton Underwood from the start. She had her challenges along the way, mainly stemming from her feud with fellow contestant Hannah Brown, but Caelynn made it to the final four. After she was sent home, we could have sworn the fan favourite would become the next bachelorette. But the choice went a different way, and now this brave woman has another shot at love.