The first death of the season is poor neighbour Natalie (Michaela McManus). She's the mysterious woman on the other side of the fence who was teased in the finale of season two, and naturally, Joe instantly becomes obsessed with her. But while Joe's obsessions often lead to murder, this time around, Love takes out Natalie in a fit of jealous rage. In the first episode, Natalie shows Love a storefront that could potentially be her new bakery, and Love kills her in the basement. She and Joe then have to dispose of the body, and her husband's attempts to solve her murder becomes one of the central storylines of the season.