Neighbourhood good guy Gil (Mackenzie Astin) openly admits to Love that he and his wife are antivaxxers, which is how his kids got baby Henry sick with the measles. Understandably frustrated, Love knocks him out. Joe and Love try to get some dirt on Gil so they can let him out of the basement cage in exchange for his silence, but when they dig up something even he didn't know, Gil dies by suicide. As a "two birds, one stone" solution, Love and Joe frame him for Natalie's murder and write a suicide-note confession.