We learn in episode one that Amy Schumer (playing a fictionalized version of herself) wants to adapt the podcast from season one into a streaming series for her to star in as Jan. Maybe she wanted to ensure a season two, so she killed Bunny for more material? We also learn in episode three that the renovations to her apartment were not pre-approved by Bunny and the board. Is the murder just a case of a real estate fight gone bad?
But this theory doesn't quite hold up. After Mabel, Charles, and Oliver throw out the painting, Amy brings it into her own apartment. If she stole the painting after killing Bunny, she probably wouldn't bring any evidence to her home. She acts irrationally in her apartment, even professing to have a deep crush on Charles, but later she tells Oliver she was just trying to get into character as Jan for her limited series.
Schumer ultimately didn't return for any more episodes and ultimately had nothing to do with the murder.
Our verdict: Not guilty, just weird