Desperate to overcome her writer's block, breakthrough music artist Layne (Dia Frampton) books a flight back home to spend New Year's Eve with her best friend Cassie. Once in Nashville, Layne pays a visit to a psychic, who advises her to return to the source that originally inspired her to write music. That night, Layne and Cassie spend their New Year's Eve on a wild goose chase as they try to track down Layne's ex-girlfriend Caroline, whom she never fully got over. However, as the night progresses, Layne begins to think that maybe Caroline was never the problem, and maybe her muse has been right beside her all along.