As one of the oldest movies on this list, Make the Yuletide Gay is an eye-opening coming out story. After living his college life as an out and proud gay man, Olaf "Gunn" returns home for the holidays. Unlike his open persona at school, Olaf is more reserved and closeted because he hasn't worked up the courage to tell his family the truth. All his efforts to force himself back in the closet are thrown out the window when his boyfriend, Nathan, shows up at his family's home unexpectedly. Olaf convinces Nathan to keep their relationship a secret until he's ready to come out, but just how long can he keep Nathan hidden?