After years of his family hounding him about being single, Peter, an LA-based social media strategist, excitedly plans to bring his new boyfriend, Tim, home for the holidays. However, Tim has been lying to Peter, and is actually secretly married to a woman. Absolutely heartbroken, Peter convinces his friend, Nick, to come along and pretend to be his boyfriend instead. The lie would be better than facing another year of his family shaming him for being single. Upon arriving at his family home in New Hampshire, Peter finds out that he's been set up with a local spinning instructor. The pair end up hitting it off, much to Nick's dismay.