Popsugar Fashion Old Navy Best Old Navy Shoes For Women 2023 Shop 19 of the Highest-Rated, Bestselling Shoes From Old Navy 12 February 2023 by Angela Elias Image Source: Old Navy As POPSUGAR editors, we independently select and write about stuff we love and think you'll like too. If you buy a product we have recommended, we may receive affiliate commission, which in turn supports our work. If you think you have to splurge to find trend-forward, comfortable shoes, you might be surprised by the options you can find at Old Navy. We've scoured online reviews, cherry-picked our favourite styles, and even put several pairs to the test to deliver our list of must-have shoes from Old Navy. Whether you're looking for something timeless or want to experiment with a trendy style without making a big financial investment, we found a great mix of both. Shop everything from sleek mules, retro-inspired clogs, cowboy boots, and classic loafers to stylish espadrilles and slip-on sandals. With most coming in several colours, it's easy to find a shoe that perfectly matches your style and wardrobe needs. Between choosing from Old Navy bestsellers and some of the highest-rated shoes (including our own honest reviews), you can feel confident in this selection of vetted options. With many pairs marked down with steep discounts — some for as little as $10 — the quality and price combination make these options a worthwhile investment. Shop our 19 favourite Old Navy shoe picks to find your new favourite pair. Faux-Suede Sherpa-Lined Clog Shoes Image Source: oldnavy.gap.com If you've even glanced at TikTok, you'll immediately know that these Faux-Suede Sherpa-Lined Clog Shoes ($25, originally $35) are a dead ringer for a popular (and much more expensive) shoe. Made with a soft-brush faux-suede upper and a faux-suede footbed, the smooth material and adjustable buckle guarantee a comfortable fit. Our editor tested them out and immediately fell for this affordable dupe. Check out her review of the Faux-Suede Sherpa-Lined Clog Shoes. Faux-Suede Sherpa-Lined Clog Shoes $25 from oldnavy.gap.com $35 $25 Now 29% off from oldnavy.gap.com Buy Now Faux-Leather Chunky-Heel Loafer Shoes Image Source: oldnavy.gap.com These Faux-Leather Chunky-Heel Loafer Shoes ($40) can instantly elevate a pair of jeans or keep a dress feeling casual enough for daytime gallivanting. Between the cushioned footbed and chunky heel, they're surprisingly comfortable but sleek enough to be versatile. After wearing them all day, our editor didn't want to take them off. "These loafers are so comfortable that it's hard to believe the price tag," she said. Check out her review of these Faux-Leather Chunky-Heel Loafer Shoes. Faux-Leather Chunky-Heel Loafer Shoes $40 from oldnavy.gap.com Buy Now Double-Strap Slide Sandals Image Source: oldnavy.gap.com Whether you need a water-resistant sandal for the pool or a cushioned sandal as light as air, these Double-Strap Slide Sandals ($7–$20, originally $20) check both boxes. Available in five different options, including a fun leopard print, you'll be tempted to buy more than one. Our editor fell for the white pair and noticed that they look similar to a much pricier celeb-loved design. Get her full thoughts in this Double-Strap Slide Sandals review. Double-Strap Slide Sandals $7 from oldnavy.gap.com Buy Now Criss-Cross Faux-Leather Sandals Image Source: oldnavy.gap.com If you need a simple yet chic pair of sandals that will go with everything, these Criss-Cross Faux-Leather Sandals ($13, originally $20) are it. With more than 800 reviews that rack up an almost perfect five-star average, there's not much to lose. After testing them out, our editor said that wearing these "feels like I'm walking on a cloud." Read her thoughts in this Criss-Cross Faux-Leather Sandals review. Criss-Cross Faux-Leather Sandals $13 from oldnavy.gap.com $20 $13 Now 35% off from oldnavy.gap.com Buy Now Faux-Leather Classic Clogs Image Source: oldnavy.gap.com The clog-shoe trend isn't going away anytime soon. If you've been curious about incorporating this style into your shoe collection, these Faux-Leather Classic Clogs ($40) are a great entryway. Reviewers note how comfortable they are, with one even saying they lend that "walking on air" feel thanks to the padded footbed. Scoop them up in this cognac brown or opt for classic black. Faux-Leather Classic Clogs $40 from oldnavy.gap.com Buy Now Water-Repellent Pull-On Chelsea Rain Boots Image Source: oldnavy.gap.com If you're tired of trying to make your leather boots work during the rainy season, do yourself a favour and invest in these Water-Repellent Pull-On Chelsea Rain Boots ($38, originally $40). Aside from keeping your toes dry, the matte PVC upper also helps resist stains, so muddy puddles really aren't a fair match. While you could go for classic black, we're very into this taupe option. Water-Repellent Pull-On Chelsea Rain Boots $38 from oldnavy.gap.com $40 $38 Now 5% off from oldnavy.gap.com Buy Now Faux-Leather Mule Shoes Image Source: oldnavy.gap.com A mule might be the most versatile flat we can think of. These Faux-Leather Mule Shoes ($28, originally $30) feel especially on-trend in this bone colour, but you can also pick them up in a cognac brown. With more than 20 reviews rating them just under five stars, they're a steal for the price. Faux-Leather Mule Shoes $28 from oldnavy.gap.com $30 $28 Now 7% off from oldnavy.gap.com Buy Now Faux-Suede Western Ankle Boots Image Source: oldnavy.gap.com Western boots are another trendy shoe style that can add a dose of bohemian flair to any outfit. These Faux-Suede Western Ankle Boots ($32, originally $40) have more than 900 reviews and a nearly perfect five-star rating. Reviewers love how easily they can be dressed up or down and give them high scores for comfort. Faux-Suede Western Ankle Boots $32 from oldnavy.gap.com $40 $32 Now 20% off from oldnavy.gap.com Buy Now Textile Lace-Up Espadrille Sandals Image Source: oldnavy.gap.com Whether you're packing for a European holiday or just want to look like you're on one, these Textile Lace-Up Espadrille Sandals ($36, originally $40) achieve the aesthetic. They're an online exclusive, so you won't find them in stores. The canvas laces allow you to adjust for comfort, and the jute soles add just enough cushiony height. Textile Lace-Up Espadrille Sandals $36 from oldnavy.gap.com $40 $36 Now 10% off from oldnavy.gap.com Buy Now Faux-Suede Espadrille Slide Sandals Image Source: oldnavy.gap.com If you'd rather not fuss with laces but still love the look of an espadrille, try these Faux-Suede Espadrille Slide Sandals ($30). Offered in three colours, this rusty "copper moon" shade is ideal for adding a subtle pop of colour. The sale price combined with a perfect five-star rating means you don't have to think twice about whether or not to buy them. Faux-Suede Espadrille Slide Sandals $30 from oldnavy.gap.com Buy Now Perforated Clog Shoes Image Source: oldnavy.gap.com Light as air and water-resistant, these Perforated Clog Shoes ($10, originally $25) are a fantastic dupe for a popular style. Wear them to the beach or with socks and sweats for a laid-back look all year long. Offered in four colours, this taupe shade might be our favourite. Perforated Clog Shoes $10 from oldnavy.gap.com $25 $10 Now 60% off from oldnavy.gap.com Buy Now Faux-Leather Ruched Sandals Image Source: oldnavy.gap.com If you need easy slip-on sandals that can be dressed up or down, we have the pair for you. Between the ruffled texture and the electric-pink shade, these Faux-Leather Ruched Sandals ($23) make a statement without feeling too over the top. Available in five colours that range from a pretty mint to a pale pink, the toughest part is deciding which pair to buy. Faux-Leather Ruched Sandals $23 from oldnavy.gap.com Buy Now T-Strap Flip-Flops Image Source: oldnavy.gap.com You can't have an Old Navy shoe roundup without acknowledging a cult classic: the Old Navy flip-flop. These T-Strap Flip-Flops ($6, originally $7) offer a modern twist on a popular classic. They come in six colours, but we adore this coral colour (aka: Spice Girl). T-Strap Flip-Flops $6 from oldnavy.gap.com $7 $6 Now 14% off from oldnavy.gap.com Buy Now Faux-Leather Puffy Braided Sandals Image Source: oldnavy.gap.com Another chic slip-on sandal option are these Faux-Leather Puffy Braided Sandals ($30). The single, cushioned strap makes them equally comfortable and stylish. They're perfect for sliding on with everything from jeans to dresses. Faux-Leather Puffy Braided Sandals $30 from oldnavy.gap.com Buy Now Soft-Brushed Faux-Suede Sneakers Image Source: oldnavy.gap.com If you're looking for an elevated sneaker to stand out from the sea of white pairs you already own, consider these Soft-Brushed Faux-Suede Sneakers ($30) in this fun cheetah print. With more than 1,000 reviews and an almost five-star rating, they deliver in style and comfort. Soft-Brushed Faux-Suede Sneakers $30 from oldnavy.gap.com Buy Now EVA Slide Sandals Image Source: oldnavy.gap.com You probably recognise this style of pillowy-soft sandals from a similar and very popular version that's made its rounds on TikTok. These EVA Slide Sandals ($22, originally $25) are the lightweight slip-ons you've been looking for if you need a casual pair. They're available in four colours, but we're especially into this pale-green shade. EVA Slide Sandals $22 from oldnavy.gap.com $25 $22 Now 12% off from oldnavy.gap.com Buy Now Faux-Leather Lace-Up Gladiator Sandals Image Source: oldnavy.gap.com A bohemian classic, these Faux-Leather Lace-Up Gladiator Sandals ($30) will never go out of style and are an Old Navy bestseller. The gold-toned tips offer a touch of glamour to this earthy style. Wear them with shorts for a low-key look, or pair them with a dress. Faux-Leather Lace-Up Gladiator Sandals $30 from oldnavy.gap.com Buy Now Plush Sherpa Slippers Image Source: oldnavy.gap.com In need of a cosy house slipper? These Plush Sherpa Slippers ($15, originally $20) offer a soft and warm option for colder months. The hard soles lend enough traction, so you don't have to worry about slips. And with more than 500 reviews that rack up an average rating of just under five stars, you can rest assured they're worth the $15 price. Plush Sherpa Slippers $15 from oldnavy.gap.com $20 $15 Now 25% off from oldnavy.gap.com Buy Now Faux-Suede Sherpa-Lined Moccasin Slippers Image Source: oldnavy.gap.com If you prefer a slipper with a closed back, consider these Faux-Suede Sherpa-Lined Moccasin Slippers ($17, originally $25). With more than 900 reviews and a rating average just under five stars, you can't go wrong. Grab them in this chestnut brown, or opt for black if you'd rather have a colour that won't show dirt. Faux-Suede Sherpa-Lined Moccasin Slippers $17 from oldnavy.gap.com $25 $17 Now 32% off from oldnavy.gap.com Buy Now Old NavyShoes