The Style: Old Navy Cosy Shaker-Stitch Mock-Neck Sweater ($40)
The Review: "I still can't believe the affordable price tag on this sweater, because the shaker-stitch weave and luxurious fabric make it both look and feel like a $100 find. It's incredibly soft and the navy blue option goes great with jeans. I love it so much I just bought it in grey as well. If you don't believe me, read all the five-star reviews on the site." — Macy Cate Williams, senior editor, Shop