Popsugar Living Toys Toys You Definitely Had If You Grew Up in the Early 2000s 33 Toys You Definitely Had If You Grew Up in the Early 2000s 1 November 2020 by Lauren Harano View On One Page Photo 33 of 33 ADVERTISEMENT () Start Slideshow Share This Link Copy ← Use Arrow Keys → 33 Tickle Me Elmo Oddly creepy yet still cute, the Tickle Me Elmo ($60) was a hit back then. Tickle Me Elmo $60 from ebay.com Buy Now Previous Next Start Slideshow ToysNostalgiaGifts