"This Birkenstock sandal is the elevated, cool version of a house shoe you'll want to wear all winter long. The shearling is so soft and comfortable, and it looks a lot more fashionable than your average slipper. Plus, if you wear it out of the house, no one will judge you." — India Yaffe, associate editor, commerce
Gift: Birkenstock Arizona Genuine Shearling Lined Slide Sandal ($160)