Eyeko 'Black Magic' Liquid Eyeliner One customer's review of the Product: Eyeko 'Black Magic' Liquid Eyeliner ($22) says it all. "I'm an avid winged eyeliner girl and I've tried countless products on the market," she wrote. "I've always come back to this one — now I keep two just in case one runs out! It's the perfect black, glides on smoothly; the tip is not stiff but also not floppy; I can do the perfect wing with it or the thinnest line across my eyes; and it doesn't fade and is waterproof but washes off so effortlessly at the end of the day. The best part is that it promotes lash growth!" Eyeko 'Black Magic' Liquid Eyeliner - No Color $22 from shop.nordstrom.com Buy Now