This Velour Lashes Fluff'N Brow Pencil - 3-in-1 Brow Pencil and Balm ($25) has both pencil and brow balm ends whether you want a feathered effect, something more defined, or a combination of the two. Plus, the formula has shea butter and avocado oil to treat skin and hair right — and 98 percent of Sephora shoppers who tried it would recommend it to you, too.