Milk Makeup Gel Brow This clean Milk Makeup Gel Brow ($18) boasts a matte formula, and has earned top marks from other Sephora shoppers for how long it lasts, how natural its gel-pencil formula looks on skin, and how easy it is to master, even for beginners. Image Source: sephora.com Milk Makeup Gel Brow $18 from sephora.com Buy Now