In May 2022, Olsen and Eisner sparked different rumours than their prior ones. This time, speculation swirled that the two were married, but those rumours were never proven. By January 2023, however, multiple outlets reported that the pair married in an intimate Bel Air ceremony on Dec. 28, 2022. According to Page Six, the special occasion was shared with a small circle of 50 guests, and celebrations went late into the night.