Alyssa and Scott had a very public relationship in the '90s; they met on the set of the film Double Dragon in June 1993 and moved in together two months later. The Party of Five star popped the question two months after that, and in a joint interview with People in 1994, Scott said, "I'm convinced we're like two halves of the same soul." While he told the interviewer, "You can interview us 25 years from now," Scott and Alyssa ended their relationship shortly after. Oops.