Halle Berry first saw Atlanta Braves all-star David Justice playing in an MTV Rock n' Jock softball game (how '90s is that?!) in 1992. A reporter later told her that David was a fan, so she gave her number to the reporter to pass on to him. They began dating and tied the knot at midnight on Jan. 1, 1993.
Unfortunately, their cuteness didn't last long; when Halle filed for a restraining order after their divorce in 1997, many accused David of domestic violence — the Oscar winner has spoken publicly over the years about an ex-boyfriend that "caused permanent hearing loss to her left ear," but has never named names. David has railed against the reports over the years, saying, "David Justice is not the person who hit her on her head and caused her hearing loss. Not only did David Justice not do that, David Justice never hit her, period."