After Alex, Lucy dated Amazing Spider-Man actor Chris Zylka for about nine months before some cryptic tweets from Chris suggested that the two were done. The duo first met at New Years Eve party, but when a fan tweeted at Chris that his "girlfriend is gorgeous" in September 2012, Chris replied, "Don't have a girlfriend. She decided she was too good."
Luckily, Chris later apologised in a series of tweets. "I'd like to apologise about my previous comments," he said. "Lucy is not only one of the most talented people I've ever had the pleasure of knowing, but also one the most beautiful, inside and out. Anyone who's ever watched, or had the pleasure of meeting her, knows this to be true."