Though David Henrie was once rumoured to be romancing his on-screen sister Selena Gomez, the Wizards of Waverly Place actor was actually dating Lucy, who guest-starred on the series in 2007 as David's love interest, Miranda. The pair dated for over two years, but when asked by J-14 back in 2014 if he would ever get back together with Lucy, David suggested that their relationship was purely platonic after their breakup. "No, we're friends. We're just buddies now," he said, so it seems as though they ended on good terms.