After Adam, Lucy was in a two-year relationship with musician Anthony Kalabretta. When asked about the relationship by People back in September 2016, Lucy had nothing but good things to say, despite some rumours of trouble in paradise. "[It's going] good," she said. "He's great."
However, according to Daily Mail, the May 2017 breakup may not have been quite so amicable, as they unfollowed each other on social media and deleted several of their Instagram pics together following the split. Then, just a month after their reported breakup, Lucy tweeted a photo of the two of them in front of a helicopter, but it may have just been as friends. She does follow Adam on Instagram again now, so it seems things are cool between them, even if they don't decide to rekindle their romance.