In 2014, Lucy dated country singer Joel Crouse for a few months. The couple was first spotted together in April 2014 at a Lakers Game, where Lucy shared an Instagram pic of the two captioned, "First lakers game. Was really great teaching this one the rules of the game. And seeing him looking like a kid in a candy store @joelcrouse." The pair split in June, and a source alleged to Us Weekly that it was due to the distance and Lucy's work demands.